Comparing Fused and Non-Fused Disconnect Architectures
The decision between a fused (e.g., GRL DNH1) and a non-fused isolator switch is one of the most common dilemmas faced by system designers. The choice is fundamentally a strategic evaluation of fault levels, equipment value, and maintenance philosophy.
The Argument for Fused Disconnect Switches
Fused disconnect switches are the preferred choice for protecting high-value assets such as industrial motors, large HVAC systems, and photovoltaic inverters. The core advantage lies in the fuse’s ability to act as a current-limiter. In a high-fault current application, a current-limiting fuse will clear a fault before the peak current is ever reached, protecting the wiring from mechanical stress and the equipment from thermal destruction.
Furthermore, fused switches simplify selective coordination. By using a 1.6:1 ratio between upstream and downstream fuse ratings, engineers can ensure that only the fuse closest to the fault blows, preventing a localized motor failure from taking down an entire production line or building.
The Role of Non-Fused Switches
Non-fused switches are appropriate in systems where overcurrent protection is already provided by a primary circuit breaker and the only requirement is a local point of isolation. They are common in residential lighting circuits, small pumps, and guest room power in the hospitality sector. Non-fused switches are generally 20-40% less expensive and more compact than their fused counterparts. However, they offer no defense against short circuits, making them unsuitable for sensitive electronic equipment or environments with high available fault currents.
Industrial Applications and Case Studies
The versatility of the GRL DNH series has led to its adoption in some of the most demanding electrical projects worldwide. These applications highlight the device’s reliability across diverse sectors.
Renewable Energy: Solar PV and Wind Power
In the photovoltaic industry, fused disconnect switches are essential in both combiner boxes and grid-connected cabinets. For a typical 1000VDC or 1500VDC solar installation, the DNH1 series provides the necessary DC isolation while protecting the strings from reverse current or surges. In wind power applications, where system voltages can reach 1140V AC, GRL’s high-voltage DNH1 models offer a breaking capacity of 50kA, ensuring the turbines are protected from the massive energy of a grid fault.
Energy Storage Systems (ESS)
In large-scale battery storage, fused disconnects are used to isolate the battery bank from the power conversion system (PCS). Given the extremely high short-circuit current available from lithium-ion batteries, GRL’s DNH1 series is often paired with Class aBat or aR high-speed semiconductor fuses to ensure the system is de-energized in microseconds in the event of an internal cell failure.
Infrastructure: Shanghai Metro Line 13
GRL provided customized electrical solutions for the tunnel boring machines used in the construction of Shanghai Metro Line 13. The project required a busway system and disconnectors that could withstand the vibrations and harsh environmental conditions of subterranean construction while allowing for easy maintenance and rapid component replacement to avoid costly project delays.